Top Catholic Songs

According to the Handbook for American Catholic Hymnals by J. Vincent Higginson, in addition to the St. Gregory melody, there are six additional melodies which appeared in the following hymnals. Mediator Dei No. 61;  the Pius X hymnal No. 56; the De LaSalle hymnal No. 41; the Alverno III hymnal No. 70; the Laudate No. 127; the Roman hymnal No. 11; the Catholic hymnal by Fr. John Hacker, S.J., No. 108; the St. Mary's Manual No. 66; and the Monastery hymna; by A. Brager's No. 58; 

The original hymn text is by Angelus Silesius (Johann Scheffler) from his Heilige Seelenlust 1657. He was a convert to Catholicism. In the Trier Gesangbuch the text is revised to "Jesu, Jesu,komm' zu mir."  Translators of the hymn include: Fr. Ernest M. Barrett and DOM S. Ould, O.S.B., and Sister Jeannie Marie, S.N.D. who is credited with the translation found in St. Gregory's hymnal.

It does appear in early American hymn books like Cantica Sacra 1865, Laudis Corona 1880, Laudate Pueri 1886, Roman Hymnal 1884, and Sodalist Hymnal 1887 which is captioned "Loving Savior come to me" 

I do have some of these hymn books and could share the different melodies.