traditional

Catholic Mass Music Debate: Should Hymns With Doctrinal Errors Be Banned?

October 22, 2025 - 10:50am — Richard Schletty

YouTube video: https://youtu.be/05zuFm9FLps

From Gregorian chant to praise and worship, EWTN News Reporter Mark Irons gives a listening ear to the Catholic Mass music debate and why one diocese banned certain hymns for a time.

A related discussion on traditional vs. contemporary, as well as what is docrtinally and musically acceptable, is here at the Musica Sacra Forum:

Market Pivot Toward Tradition in OCP's Heritage Missal
https://forum.musicasacra.com/forum/discussion/22485/market-pivot-toward-tradition-in-ocps-heritage-...

For reference, here is the USCCB paper mentioned in the YouTube video:

Catholic Hymnody at the Service of the Church: An Aid for Evaluating Hymn Lyrics
usccb.org/resources/Catholic%20Hymnody%20at%20the%20Service%20of%20the%20Church_0.pdf
Published by the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, September 2020

Watch the video, read the YouTube comments, read the Musica Sacra forum discussion, and comment below.

Read Full Story

Share this story:

User Login

Membership information

Member menu

New comments

Thanks

Timely Post

The Grotto

Thank you, Cecil.

Thaxted

Nice chord progressions and melody

Lyrics

Your joy I’ll be

Send hymn accompaniment

hymn accompaniment

O Fairest Flower of Italy hymn

Thank you

Viva Cristo Rey!

Empty handed but enriched

Great research!

We need to find Diocesan Hymnal, Part Two, Devotional Hymns

see more comments

New members

See why people have joined. Register as a member to send private messages to other members and to create your own stories.

see all members

Andy Cuddy

Catholic. I've been writing some songs. I just came across this and interested in what others are doing.

joewolfmusic

I am a Catholic Music Minister within the Diocese of Austin, Texas.

AlmosLataan

I have written a pro-life song that I would like to share. The pro-life movement is important to me, and I want to start contributing.

stpetersrecordings

I want to connect with other like minded individuals

MRS EMMA SOARES

I love Michelle Sambrano's psalm arrangements. Also any new catholic hymns.

kaypaulus

I have been writing songs inspired by our Catholic faith for about a year now, and would like to start connecting and collaborating with others.

DcnNaa

I work at a university and would like a resource for selecting appropriate music for Mass

Kfmiller

To share original Catholic music - Karl Miller.

Patmusic

To learn more about creating Catholic music

JOSEPHAT ISINGOMA

Just interested

virgilposc

to expand the Spanish repertoire of easily singable antiphons for our liturgies

Susanna J

Looking for psalms tune and music scores

Grace Lifing

Engagée dans la diffusion de la musique catholique, je cherche à partager des chants pour contribuer à l’œuvre d’évangélisation selon mes humbles moyens. Que Dieu veille sur chacun de nous !

Gill Hewitt

Beautiful inspirational music.

Suekorlan

I play the organ/ piano for my parish and am hoping to be able to get my hands on some fitting music not in our song book.

LUO CATHOLIC MUSIC

Want to promote catholic music

Quip11

I've written a Mass setting, got it approved by the USCCB, several psalm settings, and a couple years of gospel acclamation verses. Looking for a place to publish my works.

KatyMary321

To assist with the parish liturgy. I am a member of our folk group at mass and love singing a variety of hymns.

Dahlia440

Music for prison ministry

Tara

Starting to play at our church and need to practice

St Clare

I love Catholic music and I enjoy listening to the older hymns.

Clam19

my husband and I have started supporting the music ministry at our local church

KEIICHIRO YAMASAKI

I'd like to introduce catholic church and music. I am also roman catholic man, my family too.

brianjtucker

As a Catholic songwriter and singer myself, I want to contribute to the community and receive info on how to promote good Catholic songs to a wide audiences.

Kadeschepper

I am Catholic and a piano teacher. The Catholic Church has the most beautiful treasury of hymns. I want my students to study hymns. Also, I want to memorize the words of some of the hymns that are in Latin and having access to the sheet music will help with that. Thank you.

GregR

I would like to listen and comment on songs to offer encouragement, feedback, and constructive criticism.

VonBalthazar

Dare we hope that all will be saved

ckelley

to hear good Catholic Music

Bev88

I'm a music director at a Cathedral and a composer. I would love to hear other composers, music, ideas, etc. Additionally, I'd like to share my own music.

jnnfrcrbn

I like to listen to good music.

mimosa19

I am searching for a hymn sung on line in Canada - when I am confined to home and watch mass. I am a piano player for many years and would like to find the musical score.

Don9of11

To share my research on Catholic devotional hymns.

Top Organ Baba

I am an organist (80 years old) for an old small country church in Camp Morton Manitoba... I am doing research for appropriate hymns for all readings.

Rose

Lead of Catholic music liturgy

rskoreyko

mass hymn

kalewis

Searching for a song I sang in grade school

Jeremy St Martin

My Father is on here. It is great!

Masterartistspps

I will be Catholic Church Organist

ronsue

I have written and recorded about 70 songs over the last two decades. I would like to share them with a larger audience. Thank you and God bless your work Ron St Martin

Tim229

I’m looking forward to playing guitar at mass again.

boni

I am a true catholic wanted to learn more songs .

francisbernadette

I am Catholic wanting to learn more songs to sing

Kathilm8

I am a sixth grade catechist so I think using song is an excellent way to help them remember Catholic teachings.

Sburke

I am a Catechist that believes that religious song is the prayer of the angels, that lifts the soul. What better way to get a child to feel the present of God's peace

Immaculate1

Ave Maria! I want to be a registered user because I would like to download songs for creative projects I am working on.

Jude

Choir ministry

dstlouis

I sing in a Church choir and sometimes I only have the lyrics. I am looking to also have the sheet music to learn the songs before the next Mass

celinagorham

I am a practicing Roman Catholic always trying to increase my faith and holiness. I like Christian music particularly prefer Catholic Christian when I am driving or at home completing tasks.

BGONZALESTX2017

MUSIC DIRECTOR FOR CCE.

MEL0708

to learn songs I can use in my atrium with children

see all members

Top Catholic Songs

Look for songs

New posts

Active forum topics

New stories

New blog posts