Contemporary Catholic music radio: Catholic Music Express.
Click here to chat live with other TCS members. Chat is only available when logged in as a member.
Share your original music and stories. Collaborate. Become a member for free.
See why people have joined. Register as a member to send private messages to other members and to create your own stories.
Comments
Your reflection on hymn choices
"Today, some musicians use missalette guides for hymn choices, while others aim to revive Gregorian chant, both neglecting the educational value of traditional Catholic hymns. There was a time when Communion hymns of this quality were consistently part of the choir and parish repertoire."
Thanks for your complete survey of this wonderful song by Sister Mary Paulina Finn.
Richard Schletty | Schletty Design and Music | www.schletty.com
hymn choices
My reflection, particularly the comment about hymn selections, aims to encourage church musicians to appreciate traditional hymns. In my parish, our young organist is unfamiliar with traditional hymns because they are not included in the missalette. If a hymn is not listed there, it is typically excluded from the Sunday lineup. The prevailing guideline appears to be that the hymns should align with the readings, as suggested by the liturgy guides accompanying the missalettes.
Additionally, providing background information on the hymn, its author, and composer can offer valuable insight. It is my belief that many musicians select hymns based on their melodies and emotional impact, rather than contemplating the verses and the lessons they impart regarding our Catholic faith.
Then of course there is the other camp of musicians who want to reform the church according to the Vatican II documents with Gregorian chant. Granted, the church says the Gregorian chant has pride of place, but they neglect the last sixty years of hymn singing in the church and like their predecessors, they are throwing the baby out with the bath water.
www.howefamily.com
Post new comment